Emily Dickinson - "Because I could not stop for Death"

 

Emily Dickinson - "Because I could not stop for Death"

Download

Welcome to this exploration of one of American literature's most enigmatic and brilliant voices: Emily Elizabeth Dickinson (1830–1886). A prolific poet who penned nearly 1,800 poems, Dickinson lived a life of profound seclusion in her family home in Amherst, Massachusetts. Contrary to popular myth, her reclusiveness was not born of disappointment but was a conscious, chosen state that allowed her to cultivate her immense intellectual and creative powers. Her work, largely unpublished and unrecognised during her lifetime, was discovered after her death by her sister, Lavinia, and has since secured her place as a foundational figure in poetry.

Dickinson’s poetry is characterised by its piercing insight, its compression of thought, and its fearless exploration of the fundamental themes of existence: death, immortality, faith, nature, and the self. Her distinctive style—with its use of dashes, unconventional capitalisation, and slant rhyme—creates a unique rhythm and immediacy, challenging readers to look beyond the surface of things. This newsletter will delve into the core of her work, analysing two of her most defining poems, "Because I could not stop for Death" and "The Soul selects her own Society," to unpack her unique poetic vision.

The Poem – "Because I could not stop for Death"
Text of the Poem:

Because I could not stop for Death –
He kindly stopped for me –
The Carriage held but just Ourselves –
And Immortality.

We slowly drove – He knew no haste
And I had put away
My labor and my leisure too,
For His Civility –

We passed the School, where Children strove
At Recess – in the Ring –
We passed the Fields of Gazing Grain –
We passed the Setting Sun –

Or rather – He passed Us –
The Dews drew quivering and Chill –
For only Gossamer, my Gown –
My Tippet – only Tulle –

We paused before a House that seemed
A Swelling of the Ground –
The Roof was scarcely visible –
The Cornice – in the Ground –

Since then – 'tis Centuries – and yet
Feels shorter than the Day
I first surmised the Horses' Heads
Were toward Eternity –

Analysis of "Because I could not stop for Death"
Summary:

The poem narrates the speaker’s posthumous recollection of her journey with a personified Death. Death is not a terrifying figure but a "kindly" and civil gentleman who arrives in a carriage to collect her. The speaker, accompanied by Immortality, is taken on a leisurely ride through the landscape of her life, passing symbols of childhood (the School), maturity (the Fields of Gazing Grain), and the end of life (the Setting Sun). The journey culminates at her grave, described as a "House" with its roof "in the Ground." The final stanza reveals that centuries have passed, yet the memory of that day feels shorter than the moment she realised the journey's destination was Eternity.

Style and Form:

• Form: The poem is composed of six quatrains (stanzas of four lines each).
• Rhyme Scheme: It uses a loose ABC rhyme scheme with frequent use of slant rhyme (also known as half-rhyme or near rhyme). This is a type of rhyme formed by words with similar but not identical sounds. For example, in the first stanza, "me" and "Immortality" are a true rhyme, but later, "Ring" and "Sun" (Stanza 3) or "Chill" and "Tulle" (Stanza 4) are slant rhymes. This technique creates a sense of unease and incompleteness, mirroring the poem's unsettling subject matter.
• Meter: The poem is primarily written in iambic meter (an unstressed syllable followed by a stressed syllable, e.g., "be-cause"), though it frequently varies, often falling into a ballad meter rhythm (alternating lines of iambic tetrameter and iambic trimeter). This creates a slow, rhythmic, and almost hypnotic pace, mimicking the carriage's motion.
• Diction: The language is deceptively simple yet rich with symbolic meaning. Words like "kindly," "Civility," and "Gossamer" soften the macabre subject, while "quivering," "Chill," and "Swelling" introduce a subtle undercurrent of dread.

Critical Appreciation and Literary Terms:

• Personification: This is a figure of speech in which a thing, an idea, or an animal is given human attributes. Dickinson personifies Death as a genteel suitor or carriage driver. This transforms the traditional horrific image of the Grim Reaper into something more ambiguous and intriguing, making the concept of death more approachable and examineable.
• Symbolism: This is the use of symbols to represent ideas or qualities. The journey is a powerful symbol for the transition from life to eternity. Each stage of the ride is rich with symbolic meaning:

1. The School represents childhood and the playful, striving nature of life.
2. The Fields of Gazing Grain symbolise adulthood, productivity, and ripeness.
3. The Setting Sun signifies the end of life.
4. The House or grave is a symbol of the final resting place of the body.
5. The Horses' Heads pointed toward Eternity represent the soul's journey into the afterlife.

• Theme: The central theme is the confrontation and acceptance of mortality. Dickinson explores the tension between the physical finality of death (the grave) and the spiritual concept of Immortality. The poem questions whether death is an end or a transition to a new state of being.
• Imagery: Dickinson uses vivid imagery to appeal to the senses. The "Dews drew quivering and Chill" creates a tactile sensation of cold, while the visual of her inadequate clothing ("Gossamer" gown, "Tulle" Tippet) emphasises her vulnerability in the face of death's reality.
• Oxymoron: This is a figure of speech in which apparently contradictory terms appear in conjunction. The description of the grave as a "House" is a gentle oxymoron, domesticating and familiarising the unknown and frightening concept of burial.

The Poem – "The Soul selects her own Society"
Text of the Poem:

The Soul selects her own Society –
Then – shuts the Door –
To her divine Majority –
Present no more –

Unmoved – she notes the Chariots – pausing –
At her low Gate –
Unmoved – an Emperor be kneeling
Upon her Mat –

I've known her – from an ample nation –
Choose One –
Then – close the Valves of her attention –
Like Stone –

Analysis of "The Soul selects her own Society"
Summary:

This compact poem is a powerful declaration of autonomy and exclusivity. The Soul, personified as a feminine entity, exercises her absolute right to choose her company. Once she has made her selection, she shuts the door on all others, including the "divine Majority" (the rest of the world). The poem emphasises her unwavering resolve ("Unmoved") as she rejects even the most tempting offers from the powerful ("Chariots," an "Emperor"). The final stanza concludes that from a vast world of possibilities ("an ample nation"), the Soul may choose just "One" and then seal her focus as impenetrably as "Stone."

Style and Form:

• Form: The poem consists of three quatrains.
• Rhyme Scheme: It employs a more pronounced slant rhyme scheme (e.g., Door/Majority, Gate/Mat, One/Stone). This creates a sense of finality and certainty, echoing the Soul's resolute decisions.
• Meter: The meter is irregular but forceful, often using iambic trimeter and tetrameter, which gives the poem a declarative, almost ritualistic quality.
• Diction: The language is regal and absolute. Words like "selects," "shuts," "divine Majority," "Emperor," and "Valves" convey a sense of power, exclusivity, and mechanical finality.
• Personification: The core device here is the personification of the Soul as a sovereign queen. This empowers the abstract concept of the soul, making its internal, private actions seem like grand, deliberate statements of policy.

Critical Appreciation and Key Literary Terms:

• Metaphor: A metaphor is a figure of speech that directly compares one thing to another for rhetorical effect. The "Valves of her attention" is a brilliant metaphor that compares the mind's focus to a mechanical or biological valve (like that of a heart or clam), which can be shut with absolute, irreversible finality. This suggests that the soul's attention is not just a preference but a vital function that can be controlled.
• Imagery: The imagery is that of royalty and exclusion: "Chariots," "Emperor," "kneeling," "low Gate." This contrasts the external world's grandeur with the Soul's superior internal power. The final simile, "Like Stone," is a powerful image of impenetrability, coldness, and permanence.
• Theme: The central theme is the supreme autonomy of the individual self. The poem celebrates the soul's right to absolute privacy and selective engagement with the world. It is a manifesto for intellectual and spiritual independence, reflecting Dickinson's own chosen seclusion. It aligns with Transcendentalist ideas of self-reliance and the inner world being more significant than the external one.
• Hyperbole: This is deliberate exaggeration for emphasis. The rejection of an entire "ample nation" and even an "Emperor" is a hyperbole that underscores the immense, uncompromising value the Soul places on its own chosen society.

Aristotle's Poetics- Literary Criticism

The Natyashastra 

Aristotle's Poetics: The Foundational Treatise on Literary Art

Introduction:

Aristotle (384-322 BCE), the Macedonian philosopher and student of Plato, changed Western thought with his practical approach to knowledge. His Poetics (c. 335 BCE), though partially lost, remains the iconic work of literary theory. Composed as lecture notes, it systematically analyzes poetry (Greek poiētikē, "making" or "creating"), focusing mainly on tragedy and epic poetry. Aristotle counters Plato’s dismissal of art as morally corrupting by arguing poetry reveals universal truths through structured imitation (mimesis), offering intellectual pleasure and emotional catharsis. This newsletter unpacks Aristotle’s technical framework, defining key concepts crucial for understanding narrative art.

I. The Core Principle: Mimesis (Imitation)
Aristotle defines all poetry as fundamentally mimetic – not mere copying, but a creative representation of human experience.

• Mimesis :

Explanation: The artistic representation/re-creation of human actions, characters, emotions, or objects. It utilizes rhythm, language, and harmony. Unlike Plato (who saw art as a deceptive copy of copies), Aristotle viewed mimesis as natural, educational, and pleasurable. Humans learn through imitation; art purifies this instinct into meaningful patterns revealing universal truths (katholou).

Example: A tragedy imitates "noble" actions; comedy imitates "base" actions.

• Three Modes of Mimesis:
1. Medium (How): The tools used (language, rhythm, melody, spectacle).
2. Object (What): The subjects represented (people in action – better, worse, or like ourselves).
3. Manner (How Presented): Narrative form (first-person, third-person, or dramatic enactment).

II. Poetry: Definition, Origins, and Types
Poetry emerges from innate human instincts and is classified by its mimetic object and manner.

• Definition: "A medium of imitation" using rhythm, language, and harmony (separately or combined) to represent life through character, emotion, or action.
• Origins: Two innate human instincts drive poetry:
1. Instinct for Imitation (Mimesis): Learning and understanding through representation.
2. Instinct for Harmony and Rhythm: Natural pleasure in patterned sound and movement.
• Major Types (Based on Mimetic Object):

1. Tragedy: Imitates "men better than they are" acting serious, complete actions of magnitude, evoking pity and fear leading to catharsis (see Section III).
2. Epic Poetry: Imitates noble actions (like tragedy) but uses narrative form and a single meter (hexameter). Deals with great themes over long time (e.g., Homer’s Iliad).
3. Comedy: Imitates "men worse than they are," focusing on the ridiculous or ugly (but not painful or destructive), provoking laughter. (Note: Aristotle’s full analysis of comedy is lost from the Poetics).
4. Dithyrambic Poetry: Lyric poetry sung in chorus, often honoring Dionysus, using music and rhythm intensely.

III. The Anatomy of Tragedy

Tragedy is the highest form of poetry for Aristotle, analyzed through six qualitative parts.

• Definition: "An imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude; in language embellished with each kind of artistic ornament...; in the form of action, not of narrative; through pity and fear effecting the proper purgation [catharsis] of these emotions."
• Six Essential Parts (Constitutive Elements):
1. Plot : "The soul of tragedy." The arrangement of events – the causal sequence of events. Must be:
• Complete: Has beginning, middle, end.
• Of Magnitude: Sufficiently significant and complex.
• Unified: Focused on a single, central action (not necessarily adhering to the later "Three Unities" of time/place/action, though unity of action is crucial).
• Complex: Involves Peripeteia (Reversal of Fortune)

       and Anagnorisis (Recognition/Discovery).

• Peripeteia: A pivotal reversal of the protagonist's situation or intentions (e.g., Oedipus discovering he killed his father).
• Anagnorisis: A critical change from ignorance to knowledge, often triggering the peripeteia (e.g., Oedipus recognizing his true identity).
1. Character : The moral agents whose choices drive the plot. Must be:
• Good : Morally sound (relative to their station).
• Appropriate: Suited to their status/role (e.g., a warrior should be brave).
• Lifelike: Consistent and believable.
• Consistent: Behavior remains coherent unless change is motivated.
2. Thought: The intellectual element – what characters argue, prove, or express. Reflects reasoning and themes.
3. Diction : The expressive use of language – word choice, metaphor, style.
4. Song/Melody: The musical/lyrical component, especially the Chorus.
5. Spectacle: The visual elements (scenery, costumes, acting). Important but least artistic, relying on craft more than poetry itself.
• Tragic Hero: Typically a person of good reputation who suffers a downfall (peripeteia) due to a Hamartia.

• Hamartia: Often translated as "tragic flaw," but more accurately a "mistake," "error in judgment," or "missing the mark." It's an action undertaken in ignorance or stemming from character weakness, leading to unintended catastrophic consequences. It is not simple villainy.

• Catharsis :

Explanation: The purgation, purification, or clarification of the emotions of pity and fear experienced by the audience. Witnessing the hero's suffering releases these emotions in a controlled, safe environment, leaving viewers emotionally balanced and intellectually enlightened about human vulnerability and fate. The exact mechanism remains debated.

IV. Epic Poetry: Comparison with Tragedy
Epic shares tragedy's nobility but differs fundamentally in form and effect.

• Similarities:

Ø  Imitates noble characters/actions.

Ø  Requires a unified, complex plot (can use peripeteia & anagnorisis).

Ø  Contains the same parts (plot, character, thought, diction; spectacle and song less prominent).

• Key Differences:

• Aristotle's Conclusion: Tragedy is superior to Epic. While both provide pleasure in reading, Tragedy's enacted form, incorporating music and spectacle, achieves a more concentrated and powerful cathartic effect within a unified timeframe.

V. Comedy: The Fragmentary View
(Based on surviving hints in Poetics and later interpretations)

1. Definition: "An imitation of characters of a lower type... the Ludicrous being merely a subdivision of the ugly. It consists in some defect or ugliness which is not painful or destructive."
2. Object of Imitation: "Men worse than they are," focusing on the ridiculous (to geloion), involving errors or deformities that provoke laughter without causing pain.
3. Effect: Provides pleasure through amusement and the safe release of laughter at human foibles. The spectator feels superior or relieved it's not them.
4. Structure: Aristotle notes its late development compared to tragedy. He mentions Crates of Athens as an early innovator who moved beyond personal lampoon (iambic form) to generalized plots and characters.

VI. Poetic Craft: Rules and Errors
Aristotle evaluates poetry based on its mimetic purpose and execution.

• The Goal of Imitation: The poet can aim to represent:
1. Things as they are.
2. Things as they are thought to be (or said to be).
3. Things as they ought to be (idealized).
• Errors in Poetry:

Ø  Essential Errors: Flaws concerning the core act of mimesis itself (e.g., irrational behavior inconsistent with character, implausible plot twists not caused by hamartia). These damage the work's credibility and purpose.

Ø  Accidental/Peripheral Errors: Factual inaccuracies about history, science, or minor inconsistencies not affecting the plot's core logic or character consistency. Aristotle considers these less critical: "For the purposes of poetry a convincing impossibility is preferable to an unconvincing possibility."

• Judging Art: Art should be judged aesthetically based on its success in achieving its mimetic purpose (representing life as it is, as thought, or as ought to be) and eliciting the appropriate emotional/intellectual response, not solely on scientific or historical accuracy.

Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of the Poetics

Aristotle’s Poetics established the foundational vocabulary and critical framework for analyzing Western literature and drama. His concepts -mimesis, catharsis, hamartia, peripeteia, anagnorisis, the primacy of plot, and the elements of tragedy – remain indispensable tools for critics, writers, and scholars. By shifting the focus from Plato’s moral condemnation to an analysis of art’s structure, function, and psychological impact, Aristotle validated literature as a serious and beneficial pursuit capable of revealing profound truths about the human condition. Despite its fragmentary state and the loss of the comedy section, the Poetics continues to provoke debate, inspire creation, and offer timeless insights into the art of storytelling. Its empirical approach to understanding how and why poetry works ensures its place as the cornerstone of literary theory.

Glossary of Key Aristotelian Terms

ü  Anagnorisis:  Recognition or discovery; a critical change from ignorance to knowledge, often triggering the peripeteia.

ü  Catharsis:  Purgation, purification, or clarification; the effect of tragedy on the audience, releasing the emotions of pity and fear.

ü  Dianoia: Thought; the intellectual element expressed through argument or thematic content in a play/poem.

ü  Ēthos : Character; the moral qualities and motivations of the agents in a drama or poem.

ü  Hamartia: Error in judgment, mistake, or flaw; the action (often undertaken in ignorance) that leads to the tragic hero's downfall.

ü  Lexis:  Diction; the expressive use of language, including word choice, style, and metaphor.

ü  Melos:  Song or melody; the musical element of tragedy, primarily associated with the Chorus.

ü  Mimesis:  Imitation or representation; the fundamental principle that all art imitates human life and action.

ü  Mythos:  Plot; the arrangement of incidents, the causal sequence of events; "the soul of tragedy."

ü  Opsis : Spectacle; the visual elements of a tragedy (scenery, costumes, acting).

ü  Peripeteia: Reversal of fortune; a pivotal change in the protagonist's situation, often the opposite of their intention.

ü  Poiesis: Making or creating; the root of "poetry," encompassing the art of literary creation.

Share this post with your peers............

The Natyashastra

 Discovering the Foundations of Indian Performing Arts & Literary Criticism

Introduction to Indian Poetics

Introduction: The Origin of Dramatic Art

The Natyashastra, accredited to the sage Bharata Muni, stands as India’s oldest surviving discourse on performing arts, encompassing theatre, dance, music, and poetics. Composed between 200 BCE and 200 CE, it is well-regarded as the Natyaveda (Fifth Veda), synthesizing foundations from the four Vedas: speech (Rigveda), song (Samaveda), acting (Yajurveda), and emotion (Atharvaveda). 

Bharata systematized pre-existing artistic traditions into 6,000 verses, creating an encyclopaedic guide for creators, performers, and audiences. Unlike earlier fragmented works (e.g., by Parasara or Narada), the Natyashastra offers a complete framework for natya (drama) as a vehicle for moral education, aesthetic pleasure, and spiritual elevation.

I. Core Poetics & Literary Thoughts

The Natyashastra establishes foundational theories for Indian aesthetics, influencing Sanskrit and Bhasha (vernacular) literary traditions. Key concepts include:

• Rasa (Aesthetic Sentiment):
• The foundation of Indian poetics, rasa is the supreme emotional experience evoked in the audience. Bharata identifies eight primary rasas:

1. Shringara (love/beauty)
2. Hasya (comedy)
3. Karuna (pathos)
4. Raudra (fury)
5. Vira (heroism)
6. Bhayanaka (terror)
7. Bibhatsa (disgust)
8. Adbhuta (wonder)

• Later theorists like Abhinavagupta (10th–11th century CE) added Shanta (tranquility) as the ninth rasa.

• Rasa arises from the interplay of vibhava (determinants), anubhava (consequents), and vyabhicaribhava (transitory emotions).

• Bhava (Emotional States):
• Bhavas are the emotional states that manifest rasa. They are categorized into:

• Sthayibhava (8 enduring emotions, e.g., love, anger).
• Vyabhicaribhava (33 transitory emotions, e.g., anxiety, envy).
• Sattvikabhava (8 involuntary physical reactions, e.g., tears, trembling).

• Abhinaya (Expression):
• The technique of "carrying meaning to the audience" through four modes:

1. Angika (body: gestures, postures).
2. Vachika (speech: dialogue, meter, modulation).
3. Aharya (external: costumes, makeup).
4. Sattvika (internal: emotional authenticity).

• Dharmi (Conventions):
• Two performance styles:

• Lokadharmi (realistic, mundane representation).
• Natyadharmi (stylized, symbolic theatricality).

• Vritti (Styles of Narration):
• Four modes of expression tailored to evoke rasa:

• Bharati (verbal emphasis).
• Sattvati (emotional emphasis).
• Kaisiki (graceful, lyrical).
• Arabhati (energetic, forceful).

III. The Ten Forms of Drama (Dasarupakas)

Bharata classifies rupakas (visual performances) based on plot, heroes, and rasa dominance:

1. Nataka (Heroic Romance):

• Plot: Well-known epics (e.g., Ramayana).
• Hero: Divine/kings (e.g., Rama in Uttararamacharita).
• Rasa: Shringara or Vira.
• Acts: 5–10; avoids direct violence (uses interludes).

2. Prakarana (Social Drama):

• Plot: Original stories of commoners (e.g., merchants).
• Hero: Brahmin/merchant (e.g., Mricchakatika).
• Rasa: Shringara.

3. Samavakara (Mythological Spectacle):

• Plot: Gods vs. demons (e.g., Samudramanthanam).
• Structure: 3 acts; 12 heroes; mixes joy/sorrow.
• Rasa: Vira supported by Shringara.

4. Ihamrga (Divine Conflict):

• Plot: Gods fighting over women (e.g., Rukminiharana).
• Rasa: Shringara; avoids battles (focus on abduction).

5. Dima (Supernatural Epic):

• Plot: Grand conflicts (e.g., earthquakes, eclipses).
• Characters: Gods/demons (16+ heroes).
• Rasa: Excludes Shringara/Hasya.

6. Vyayoga (Heroic One-Act):

• Plot: Single-day battle (e.g., Madhyamavyayoga).
• Rasa: Vira; minimal female roles.

7. Anka (Tragic Monodrama):

• Plot: Lamentation post-catastrophe (e.g., Unmatta Raghava).
• Rasa: Karuna; one act.

8. Prahasana (Satirical Farce):

• Types: Suddha (mockery of elites) or Samkirna (vulgar humor).
• Example: Mattavilasa Prahasana.

9. Bhana (Monologue):

• Structure: Single actor narrates others’ voices (e.g., Sringarabhushana Bhana).
• Rasa: Shringara/Adbhuta.

10. Vithi (Intimate Play):

• Scope: One act; 1–2 characters; all rasas.
• Features: 13 stylistic devices (e.g., soliloquies).

Uparupakas (minor forms) like Natika (Ratnavali) blend elements of Nataka and Prakarana.

IV. Literary & Cultural Legacy

The Natyashastra’s influence permeates Indian arts:

• Theory: Commentaries by Abhinavagupta (Abhinavabharati) expanded rasa theory into a universal aesthetic philosophy.

• Theatre: Rules for plot (itivritta), diction (kavya), and staging informed classical plays (Kalidasa, Bhavabhuti).

• Dance: Codified Angika abhinaya (e.g., mudras in Bharatanatyam).

• Music: Defined swaras (notes), talas (rhythms), and instrumentation (Chapter XXVIII–XXXIV).

• Modern Relevance: Principles of rasa and abhinaya support contemporary Indian cinema, theatre, and dance.

V. Conclusion: The Eternal Fifth Veda

Bharata’s Natyashastra excels a mere technical guide. It positions natya as a sacred, transformative experience—yajna (sacrifice) for the modern age. By integrating ethics (dharma), emotion (bhava), and artistry (shilpa), it asserts that drama mirrors the cosmos: "Nothing in the world exists that cannot be represented in natya" (NS I.116). For scholars of Sanskrit poetics or Bhasha literatures, it remains the bedrock of India’s aesthetic universe, where art is both a celebration of life and a path to enlightenment.

"When the world, oppressed by sorrow,
sought refuge in entertainment,
Brahma created the Fifth Veda—
the Natyaveda, accessible to all."
— Natyashastra I.14–17

Share this newsletter to ignite cultural conversations and keep Bharata's legacy alive!